{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For the past three years, the average home in the U.S. has consistently sold for higher prices compared to the previous year, month after month. This trend has now come to an end. Data for October reveals that the median sale price has dipped slightly below last year's figure, marking the first decrease since the spring of 2023. Concurrently, the available inventory of homes has surged to its highest level since early 2020, pending sales have hit their lowest mark outside the early pandemic period in over ten years, and nearly one in five listings has seen a price reduction.

However, there's a downside, borrowing costs have increased once more. The average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has climbed back into the mid-7% range after a brief period of improvement. This shift means while buyers may have new negotiating power, many find that monthly payments are still a strain on their budgets.

This unique situation presents different dynamics in the real estate market. Sellers are experiencing fewer offers and extended listing durations, signaling that the listed price and terms can now be seen more as an initial proposition rather than a finalized agreement. If you're on the hunt for a home this winter, consider what aspects might be negotiable and how to approach discussions with your agent and lender.

The implications of a minor price decline

A national drop of less than half a percent does not indicate a complete market meltdown, nor does it imply uniform price declines everywhere. Certain high-value coastal markets with limited inventory continue to see significant price growth, whereas several large metropolitan areas in the South and West have experienced price reductions of several percentage points year-over-year. It's crucial to remember that your local market context is much more relevant than national trends.

The national statistics suggest a shift in market dynamics. When homes linger on the market longer and competition among listings intensifies, sellers may become more amenable to negotiations. This newfound openness can translate into both price adjustments and modifications to the sale terms.

Price isn't the only factor

While many buyers concentrate solely on the home's purchase price, in a climate of high interest rates, the overall monthly payment and cash required at closing can hold even greater significance. A reduction of a few thousand dollars in the purchase price provides marginal savings on your loan; however, that same amount allocated wisely elsewhere may prove more beneficial for your budget. In a market like this, buyers often engage in discussions regarding:

  • A lower purchase price compared to the list price
  • Credit from the seller towards closing costs
  • Completion of necessary repairs before finalizing the sale or credits in lieu of repairs
  • Seller-funded assistance to lower your mortgage rate
  • A closing date that aligns with your schedule
  • Inclusion of items like appliances or window coverings with the home

Your real estate agent is familiar with the local market's seller responses and can guide you on which requests to prioritize in your offer. Strive to focus your negotiations on elements that will have the most significant impact on your situation.

Alleviating the cash burden with closing cost credits

Closing costs typically amount to several percent of the mortgage value, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time buyers, accumulating the necessary cash can be the most significant hurdle. A seller credit can offset some of these costs, allowing you to bring less cash to closing.

It's important to know there are limits. Various loan programs restrict the amount a seller can contribute, usually between 3% and 9%, depending on the loan type and the down payment size. Additionally, credits generally cannot exceed your actual closing costs. Consult your lender early in the process to determine the specific allowances for your loan, ensuring your requests during negotiations are compliant.

Understanding how a rate buydown functions

With interest rates above 7%, sellers may assist with your mortgage interest rate as a beneficial offering. There are two predominant structures for rate buydowns.

A permanent buydown entails purchasing discount points at closing to reduce your interest rate for the duration of the loan. Every point costs 1% of the loan amount, and the rate reduction achieved varies by lender and market conditions. If you plan to maintain the loan for many years, this option can prove advantageous.

A temporary buydown lowers your payments in the first year or two. A common scenario would see the rate drop by two percentage points in the initial year and one point in the next before reverting to the full rate. For example, on a $350,000 loan at approximately a 7.34% interest rate, the monthly payment would start at about $2,409. With a temporary buydown, the payment in the first year would be approximately $1,952, rising to about $2,176 in the second year, before reaching the full amount in the third year. This arrangement would require slightly over $8,000 in funding, something a seller may prefer to offer instead of lowering the price equivalently.

Keep in mind, while a temporary buydown can ease initial costs, it won't provide a long-term solution. You'll need to ensure you can handle the full payment once the period of discount concludes, and lenders generally assess your qualifications based on this full amount. Should rates decline later on, refinancing could be a possibility, though it's unpredictable whether and when that will occur.

Inspections shouldn't be overlooked

In competitive markets, numerous buyers opted to forgo inspections or limit their requests in an attempt to triumph in bidding wars. However, in a slower market, the urgency to waive those protections decreases. A thorough inspection provides vital insights into the condition of the home's roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical, and foundations prior to purchase.

If the inspection identifies issues, your agent can advise you on whether to pursue repairs, a price adjustment, or a credit. Asking for credits might result in fewer complications than asking the seller to manage repairs since you decide the contractors and processes involved, although making the right choice will depend on the issue at hand and your loan specifications.

Prepare your financing beforehand

Having negotiating power is futile if your financing is unstable. When evaluating two offers, sellers typically lean toward buyers who appear most capable of closing the deal. Before you start looking seriously, secure a complete preapproval rather than just a quick prequalification. Understand your optimal monthly payment rather than solely focusing on the maximum loan amount, and assess estimates from various lenders. Inquire with each lender about how they manage seller credits or buydowns to avoid any surprises later in the process.

Key questions to discuss with your agent

  • How long are homes in this area typically on the market, and how frequently do prices drop?
  • Would a price concession, a closing cost credit, or a rate buydown present the most substantial benefit for my budget?
  • How does the condition and history of this particular property influence my negotiating strategy?
  • What contingencies should I maintain in my offer to safeguard my interests?

Final thoughts

A softer market does not inherently mean lower buying costs, especially with rising mortgage rates. However, it does offer prepared buyers additional opportunity to negotiate favorable terms that align with their financial situations. By securing solid financing, having clear priorities, and seeking guidance from your agent and lender, you may find favorable terms that weren't conceivable just a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Send Us a Message